Which Gucci?

I love these two bags. Both have the same price $475 Ouch! I couldn't decide which one to go with. Can someone please help me to pick one. Please..please..
1. I think I should get this one since the design is different from my other handbags. But I'm afraid I will look old.

2. I have a Coach bag that have pretty much the same design like this one. I think I should pick something different. But I kinda like this one better